Welcome to mybenz | mysatisfaction !, Register here.. | Home | Directory | Events | Forum | Buy and Sell | Contact Us | Planet Mybenz  
Recent Forum Topics
Topic Replies/
Views
Last Post
TT Session in Penang 2018 14/5552 2021/4/16 18:19 Golfer
Selamat Berpuasa 0/37 2021/4/13 11:46 Golfer
Revive Mybenz.org 0/294 2021/4/6 17:12 Golfer
Re: Please pray and Doa for our founder Buckrey. Passed away 27th Jan 2021. Al-Fatihah 9/782 2021/3/7 23:58 cossie_mozzie
w211 E220 alternator replacement 0/112 2021/3/6 18:35 azlanzj
Happy New Year My fellow Benzerz 2/473 2021/1/25 18:30 Golfer
Revive MYBENZ 5/1790 2021/1/23 13:21 Golfer
Towbar for W124 saloon - to give away 0/171 2021/1/13 11:50 pongee
W220 Suspension Conversion Kit 0/1552 2020/11/29 22:36 Praba
Tangki air wiper 0/1532 2020/11/3 12:46 sawa
RECOMMENDED ATF BRAND/GRADE FOR E200 W211 3/1705 2020/10/31 8:29 RS-W124
WHO R YOU? 337/58909 2020/10/21 10:57 Golfer
updated tire price list 218/111250 2020/8/22 18:24 lgxrkz
Hello guys 1/2093 2020/7/29 15:01 sjchoo
C250 Aircond leak 6/1153 2020/7/29 14:52 sjchoo
GET TO KNOW : Our States Penghulu!! 86/25333 2020/7/7 12:12 Golfer
TT session 2020 in Penang 4/4119 2020/6/19 23:01 Golfer
W124 E280 MP PArts and Maintenance 2/2086 2020/6/13 8:28 raz
Mercedes Mechanics, AC Man, Wireman, Tireshop 21/13032 2020/5/20 12:32 timyap
1989 W124 300CE stalling while slowing down 2/4100 2020/5/20 12:16 timyap
W212 E-Classe Owners 76/20763 2020/4/9 22:17 dushendra
W220 S280 facelift 0/1723 2020/4/9 22:10 dushendra
W245 B170 Transmission Visit Workshop error 0/2626 2020/4/1 21:42 Brother
Repair Lamella Sunroof W245 B170 0/1584 2020/4/1 19:44 Brother
Banner Battery 2/3741 2020/2/28 23:04 Golfer
Black stain on saddle brown nappa seats 0/2155 2020/1/30 21:54 Rey
Merry Christmas 0/3364 2019/12/24 22:45 Golfer
Dynamic shock absorbers replacement 3/3547 2019/12/6 15:31 126208W
Flipkey replacement needed 0/1731 2019/11/17 0:34 alvin488
How to activate Navi in W204 0/1751 2019/11/14 16:42 MaN_MoRiNi
W211 aircond wshop 1/2311 2019/11/5 19:16 JavaKajang
w210 SERVICE CENTER(CHEAP AND BEST) 1/2359 2019/9/22 16:53 han
SRS LIGHT ON - 124 0/3363 2019/9/10 16:05 skcsec
W210 half cut Front Bumper 0/2227 2019/9/5 17:30 dudelouv
W202 C220 1996 auto 0/3039 2019/8/24 21:02 aridz1
W212 windscreen replacement in JB 3/3654 2019/8/21 13:23 alexl
C200 W204 2011 Facelift - A personal review 260/50468 2019/8/14 5:50 enkil
190E 2.6 (Manual) 0/3982 2019/7/4 12:08 cossie_mozzie
Genuine Mercedes Benz E280 Masterpiece W124 (SOLD) 0/5021 2019/6/17 17:04 cossie_mozzie
Ideal engine transplant for 190E 2/3727 2019/6/14 9:56 cossie_mozzie
car idle and stall 5/3108 2019/6/11 22:48 Golfer
vibration on rev 1/3758 2019/5/15 21:00 Gan
Anyone knows what this button is? 3/4999 2019/5/15 18:42 Plinker
REPAIR MILEAGE METER - 124 MODEL 6/4188 2019/5/7 17:43 Plinker
Two Doors with or without tops Mercedes Members 214/46673 2019/4/11 14:55 126208W
Auxiliary fan brand recommendation 1/3924 2019/4/7 0:16 shiningstar
E300 HYBRID ( Blue tech) Diesel 0/3889 2019/3/26 22:44 SERVICOM
Groovy Sunshade Bulk Purchase 15/11090 2019/3/18 1:17 techjack
Madeline 19/7436 2019/3/4 12:17 deezed
Kipas laju sedangkan temperature 80-95 0/3668 2019/2/26 15:54 adhary
Login
Username:

Password:


Lost Password?

Register now!
Refine Search
Main Menu
Quick Access
Who's Online
45 user(s) are online (35 user(s) are browsing Forum)

Members: 0
Guests: 45

more...
Location and Benz Model
Please add your location and benz model by clicking on your "edit account" link . That way it will help other members to help you identifying your benz related problem or probably help locating nearest workshop for you .
Members vs Models
Vintage | A-Class | W123 | W124 | W126 | W140 | W201 | W202 | W203 | W210 | W211 | W220 | 
B-Class | M-Class | W204 | W221 | W212 | 2-Doors | R107 | R129 | R170 | R171 | R230
mybenz | mysatisfaction Forum Index
   W204 - C Classe
     C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Register To Post

Threaded | Newest First Previous Topic | Next Topic | Bottom
Poster Thread
aficionado
Posted on: 2012/4/19 3:30
Just can't stay away
Joined: 2012/4/18
From: Batu Pahat, Johor
Posts: 131
Benz Model: W204 C200K Sport
Message:
C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Hi all

I'm a student currently studying in the UK...i'm planning to buy a used C200K Sport (2007) to bring back to malaysia..
I'm considering a manual gearbox one (due to its low price)..but I wonder if that's a good idea..
Actually I do prefer auto to manual...but I think there's nothing wrong with manual (except the typical resale value reason)...but I did find two uneasy comments (videos) about a manual gearbox as you all can see here:

1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FdLB3US3CI (min 1:40)
2. http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/front_website/video.php?id=200421 (min 1:30)
3. and this one is taken from this link:
"The foot-operated parking brake is old-fashioned and a pain to use with a manual transmission, since you have to deal with four pedals in the footwell. The manual gearlever is cheap and resonates under acceleration. Combined with a slack shift action, it falls short of the mechanical excellence you’d expect from a sporting saloon. A springy clutch and a throttle pedal with a lazy response also numb the driving experience."

And one more thing, I can't find a used C200K Sport 2007 (Manual) in motor trader Malaysia...so that makes me wonder if I'll be the only person to have it in Malaysia (i hope i'm wrong)...and even worse, where do I get the parts if there are related problems (since everybody is using auto)?

Once again, the main reason for me to consider a manual transmission one is because of its low prices (£2k-£3k difference with auto)...and better MPG <-- just nak sedapkan hati

Please help guys...i do not want to have any regret after buying it..
ismaia
Posted on: 2012/4/19 6:42
Certified Benzitos
Joined: 2008/7/9
From: Kelumpor
Posts: 1118
Benz Model: W203, W204
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?

With the kind of traffic we have in Malaysia, choose automatics. Unless you live in Rantau Petronas and work in Paka.

In terms of tax, Kastam do not differentiate manual or auto when calculating, so you don't get any bonus there.

Nevertheless, I know a friend who owns a W211 E200K Manual imported from the UK. He is still driving it and happy with it. He get offers from mechanics as it is manual gearbox, very rare in Malaysia.

The foot operated pedal is way up when brake is released, so I don't really see it as an annoyance. Who peeks down at the foot well while driving, you use your instincts.

The review is subject to the person's observation. If you really want to verify, test drive one and see for yourself if there is resonance etc.

But yes, it is rare for a manual.

And you'll miss steering pedal shifters fitted on some Sports.


----------------
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Membership no.: 3240
C220CDi, C250CGI

shamburke
Posted on: 2012/4/19 9:05
Promo Masta
Joined: 2011/4/27
From: USJ
Posts: 1091
Benz Model: W201, W210
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
the sifu has spoken....

good info here...


----------------

r1d3r
Posted on: 2012/4/19 10:41
Quite a regular
Joined: 2012/4/4
From:
Posts: 58
Benz Model: c200k
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?

for me, it depends on where are am i going to use it later in malaysia and for what purpose.

if it is going to be in KL/Selangor for daily commute, then it must be an auto for me.

in terms of resale value, current price of £2k-£3k lesser will be compensated later with maybe rm10-rm15k drop. Hence, no appreciable effect i reckon.

hope that helps
renngrun
Posted on: 2012/4/19 12:21
Home away from home
Joined: 2010/7/20
From: Shanghai/Shenzhen/Minsk/Dnepr
Posts: 4455
Benz Model: W210 E320
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
As what the others have spoken, I say....get an auto.

I'm a manual guy thru and thru. Only my Benz is automatic. I hate slushboxes but an MBZ warrants an autobox since it fits the image of a er..Benz perfectly.

To further the argument, what you saw in the vid is correcto mundo. Also the fact that MBZ does terrible manual gearboxes. Longish throws and vague slots and dead clutch pedal. No offence to a buddy here, RAD who drives a 6spd manual 203 but I've driven the manuals (W203/W124/R129/W126) before and it sucks plenty.

But it's yer choice. If you test and like the manual. Go for it. Yer money, yer call. Depreciation wise, it could work FOR you since by the time you can and want to sell it on, the punters interested in a C-Klasse would prolly be younger guys who like the idea of a manual 6 speeder.



----------------
Money Drives Women Horny - Willie Nelson

mal
Posted on: 2012/4/19 13:43
Certified Benzitos
Joined: 2010/8/2
From: ipoh
Posts: 1421
Benz Model: W201/202/203
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
bro,

to me there`s not much difference between a M and an Auto.
all u need for a M is a strong left leg.
performance wise not much difference too except like u said
maybe the mpg on the M is a bit better.
the century dash pun not much diff. 0.5-1 sec quicker for
the M, but who on earth will notice that diff. if u
try it without a stop-watch.

my advice same like renn, my merc is my first auto car,
before this all are manuals(> 10 cars) and my GOD,
i should have bought autos`starting with my first car lagi.
(maybe dulu2 not much traffic jam jadi M kira ok la)

or maybe my age dah senja kot.....

as`kum.


----------------
AGE GIVES US ENOUGH WISDOM TO SLOW DOWN,
SOMETHING WE ALL LACKED DURING OUR YOUTH.

Mabel
Posted on: 2012/4/19 22:12
Benzo mania
Joined: 2007/8/7
From: Shah Alam, Cyber Jaya, Sunway
Posts: 20053
Benz Model: S320L, E240, C200
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Go for Auto...


----------------
Cheers/Mabel

Nothing great was ever achieved without enthusiasm
Take time to read. It is the fountain of wisdom
Membership Number: One Nine Seven Seven

aficionado
Posted on: 2012/4/19 22:24
Just can't stay away
Joined: 2012/4/18
From: Batu Pahat, Johor
Posts: 131
Benz Model: W204 C200K Sport
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Hi all

Thanks for your reply and suggestion..I'm still young..and will not be commuting a lot in KL/Selangor (since I'm from Johor and will be working in Johor)...so that's why I'm okay with manual transmission...

But I guess for now my priority is auto transmission...tapi kalau dah rezeki kat manual, I'm more than happy to have it

Anyway guys, your views are very much appreciated...

One more thing (please let me know if I have to open a new thread for this), what are your opinions on having satnav in the car? I doubt it will be as good as in the UK...and can I install a reverse camera which will be connected to the satnav lcd screen (if I have one)?
Sweetner
Posted on: 2012/4/19 23:27
Quite a regular
Joined: 2008/8/13
From: Virginia
Posts: 59
Benz Model: W202, W210, W211
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Why car is call Automobil? Bcoz it is automatic + mobil=automobil. Not manualbobil. So go for automatic. You will regret if you choose manualmobil.
aficionado
Posted on: 2012/4/19 23:35
Just can't stay away
Joined: 2012/4/18
From: Batu Pahat, Johor
Posts: 131
Benz Model: W204 C200K Sport
Message:
Re: C200K Sport - auto or manual transmission?
Quote:

Sweetner wrote:
Why car is call Automobil? Bcoz it is automatic + mobil=automobil. Not manualbobil. So go for automatic. You will regret if you choose manualmobil.

haha..nice one
(1) 2 3 4 5 »
Threaded | Newest First Previous Topic | Next Topic | Top

Register To Post